Breaking up is hard to do, but it's also one of life's inevitabilities. Sometimes, things end in a way that leaves the door open for a friendship, but the road between Break-Up County and Friendshipville is a perilous journey, fraught with hidden emotional booby-traps. It's also a road you have to walk with purpose: it's nearly impossible to just kind of, like, stumble into a friendship with an ex. Deciding to stay friends is an act of bravery, but it's one that attests to the fact that, even though you and your ex are no longer in love, it's still possible to like each other.
Almost everyone, in the early moments of a break-up, says, "But I want to stay friends." The dumper uses that line to assuage guilt, while the dumped considers friendship a useful tool in winning them back. In both cases, the friendship isn't a result of two people genuinely liking each other; there's a hidden emotional subtext that's covered in dirt, bad feelings, and weirdness. "But I want to stay friends" isn't a binding contract. Feelings will change, and a friendship that seemed impossible in the first few days after a break-up will slowly start seeming like it has a chance, and vice versa. If you've said, "But I want to stay friends," you're under no obligation to stick with that.
Also, take some time apart. Some folks set the clock at six months without contact, other say "half the total time you were together." Whatever formula you use, there's no denying the benefits. Refocus on what's important to you - not for the relationship, but your own needs and wants. If, after a few months, you and your ex get together for a coffee, you may decide that pursuing a friendship is a good idea. Awesome! Or you might decide that this person is a human trashpile. Also totally fine! This transition is rarely easy, and putting pressure on yourselves to get over the relationship and into the friendship doesn't help. Being alone helps you ask yourself: how much do I like this person? How much do I like myself when I'm with them?
There are a few different forms a post-relationship friendship can take. You might go through some, or all, of these before you settle. Take your time.
Friends With Benefits: losing your sex life can be one of the most daunting things about breaking up. In an effort to avoid celibacy, some exes never stop having sex. On the outside, this looks an awful lot like dating, but both parties insist that there's no romance - they're just getting their rocks off. Unfortunately, this makes it tough to move on, grieve, or meet new people. Many exes who try this find themselves back together, and because the focus in being Friends With Benefits is willfully not on the emotional connection, the re-couples usually encounter the same issues that forced their first break-up. It's possible to avoid that by talking frankly about boundaries and expectations, but it's also complicated by the emotional hangover of the break-up. Seriously: take some distance.
Neutral: Best described as "friendly, but not friends," this requires almost no work and zero maintenance. These people exchange small talk when they run into each other on the streetcar, wish each other happy birthday on Facebook, and basically have no real communication. There's no ill will, per se; they just don't want to be a part of each other's lives after the break-up. This is pretty easy to accomplish after a short, breezy relationship, and doubly so if you don't run in overlapping social circles (did someone say, "internet dating?).
Hate: In the weeks after my first real heartbreak, I made an effort to spend time with my ex in a misguided attempt to prove that, despite being brutally dumped, I was still awesome. He couldn't care less; he had already started dating someone else. After a few months of misery, I realized that I was angry. Like, really angry, and being around the source of my rage was eating me alive. I cut off the "friendship," because the benefits of staying in touch were not outweighed by the drawback of having to spend time with him. It may take a while for you to realize that, after the relationship ends, you don't actually like your ex all that much - betrayal or infidelity has coloured your perception of them to a degree that you can't pretend to like them. Friendship? Off the table. Don't feel bad about it.
The Faux-riendship: When exes get together, conversation consist of things that don't get said. Fake friendships aren't built on real openness, but a mutual desire to shove things under the rug and pretend everything's fine. If there's a lot of sexual tension, or if one ex brings up "the good old days" a little too often, or if you avoid talking about new partners (theirs or yours), or if you have nothing to talk about but keep hanging out anyway, then the faux-riendship has you in its grasp. It's not a tragedy - with more openness, you can upgrade into an Actual Friendship, and with less, you can slide into Neutral territory - but it's tough to maintain for long.
The Actual Friendship: This is the real winner: when there's no (or few) residual feelings from the relationship, when both people are integrated into the other's post-break-up life, when hanging out isn't fraught with sexual tension or words unsaid. These rare friendships take months or years to develop. There are boundaries - every friendship has areas that just aren't really talked about - but the mutual affection dwells in the present, rather than trying to preserve the past.
Saturday, February 18, 2012
Monday, February 13, 2012
We Need To Talk About Chris Brown
Can we talk about Chris Brown for a minute? I've never really followed his career, although I did, like 72 million other people, watch the "JK Wedding Entrance Dance," and I'll admit it: I like that song. But the rest of his stuff has been overshadowed by the time he beat the shit out of his girlfriend.
Remember that, guys? It was like, three years ago. Three years ago, when Brown was nineteen years old, he was involved in a "domestic dispute" that resulted in felony assault charges. The media reaction was mixed - instead of condemning Brown for hitting, punching, and biting his girlfriend, stars spoke out about how "they didn't have the details" and "they knew both of them, and it was a sad situation." Very few celebrities took a stand and said that Brown was despicable, and those who did got shushed. Fans came out to say that they would gladly get punched in the face if it meant a lifetime of Brown's music. The mainstream media framed it as a question - does Chris Brown deserve a second chance?
There were regrets. Tears. A softball Larry King interview. Later, there was a Good Morning America piece that enraged Brown, causing a public temper tantrum that was widely reported. Brown's media now always included a qualifier - "bad boy," "controversial" - and reviews of his albums mentioned his personal life.
And then three years later, Brown was back. Back at the Grammys - three years ago, he had to cancel because he had attacked his girlfriend and was too busy dealing with the fallout to attend, but last night he was there, accepting an award and smiling and dancing and generally acting like it was his comeback. Music fans were divided: Twitter erupted with sardonic and angry comments every time Brown was onstage, but the industry seemed fine with him being there, fine with him sharing the room with his victim.
Oh yeah: his victim. Rihanna. She's doing fine now, isn't she? She poses in bikinis and has number-one albums. She's a success story. So why are we still talking about her assault? Why does it still matter?
Because Rihanna is lucky. Not lucky she was beaten - that's not "bad luck" or any kind of luck, because luck has nothing to do with it, since it's always somebody's choice to be an abuser - but lucky she survived. Lucky that she had friends and family around her. She's lucky that the public doesn't insist on remembering her solely as a victim, so she's been able to create a persona of empowerment. Because she's an entertainer, we've been privy to that transformation. That's the right of the victim: to reject the label, or to say, "I was that person for a minute, but I'm not there any more." To live forever under the shadow of someone else's mistake doesn't have to be your fate, and Rihanna has embraced her success and refused to allow Brown's assault to define her.
But Brown? Oh no. The privileges of the victim don't extend to the aggressor. The internet got buzzy around the idea that Brown deserves a reprieve from being branded an abuser. As though that's something he's grown out of, like an old pair of jeans. But he's proven time and again to be aggressive, resorting to tantrums when he doesn't get his way. He's shown little remorse. His persona - smooth lover, cool guy - is directly at odds with his proven public life, and he shows a shocking lack of awareness at how that reads to the general public.
That the music industry even acknowledges Brown, let alone awards him, is baffling. I know there's money and politics involved, but frankly, Brown shouldn't be here. He is repugnant. And we know that, make us all complicit in Brown's continued success.
Friday, February 10, 2012
XOXO Love
I've started getting paid for some writing, and I have to tell y'all, it's nice. I've been picked up as a blogger for XOXO Amore, a sister site to Seduction - yes, that Seduction - and while Seduction's focus is pretty much on bedroom toys (and outfits and swings and all the naughty accessories to the bedroom toys), XOXO Amore takes a more 360-degree approach to the questions of love, dating, romance and sex.
The first time I ever wrote about sex, I was in the ninth grade. I was trading dirty emails with a summer-camp boyfriend. He wrote half-hearted missives about how awesome it was going to be to do each other next summer. I wrote elaborate fantasy scenes that were, to my huge embarrassment, ferreted out by my parents, who were totally grossed out. I think it was because of those emails that the internet was monitored basically the entire time I lived at home. I don't blame them - home internet access was still a novelty then, and it was a digital Wild West. They didn't want me turning into the slutty saloon girl.
I've always been a reader, and a writer, and to me, putting pen to paper and describing all my sexiest thoughts came naturally. My parents were, of course, horrified by the thought of their ninth-grader having sex, but I wasn't describing things I was going to do, or even really wanted to do - I was writing about the things that excited me. When I moved into the dorms my freshman year, my laptop hummed into the night as I read erotica. It was all so chaste - having two other girls living in the same room meant that I would have passed any hand-check with flying colours - but the titillation from finally being able to look, and read, and see, was undeniable.
Student co-op housing opened my world. My dorm had been Catholic, run by actual, habit-wearing nuns, and my parent's house had been, well...my parent's house. But this place! All kinds of people lived with me: gay men, straight women, the sexually active and the celibate. Girlfriends openly discussed the sex they had with their boyfriends, people hooked up and then drifted apart, and there were group shopping trips to Good For Her in order for everyone to buy toys. (We compared notes: one model was likened to a hyperactive mouse. I'll keep that image with me until I die.)
It was mostly just a relief to be open. Things weren't weird or shameful - we all have our preferences and proclivities, and it was liberating to unabashedly own them. I realized that talking about sex was like talking about damned near anything else - it's easy, once you know how. My friends and housemates taught me how to be open. I still love them for it.
A few years late, I drunkenly accost my new friend Erika at a New Year's Eve party and tell her how much I love writing, and how much I like talking about sex. Graciously, she looks past my red-wine teeth and sets me up with the XOXO Amore gig, which she's started a few months before. I'm slightly embarrassed about the red-wine teeth, but as I start writing for the site, I realize, hey, this is fun. And I'm good at it.
The XOXO Amore vibe isn't "all sex, all the time:" they write about sexy stuff, sure, and plenty of it. I debated whether or not I should tell my mom about this new gig - on one hand, she'd be proud of me, on the other hand, probably grossed out again. But the site administrators have also put a large emphasis on dating and romance - restaurant reviews that'll suit couples are posted alongside reviews of bondage gear. It's a mixed bag, but so is dating, and love, and sex. And parents. And writing.
Friday, February 3, 2012
Pink Ribbons, Broken Promises
I've been reading a lot about the Susan G. Komen Foundation's recent decision to defund Planned Parenthood - the not-insubstantial yearly grant of $680,000 was given to 19 of the 85 American Planned Parenthood outposts and used primarily to deliver breast cancer screening like mammograms, and has since been cancelled, and then reinstated, with a somewhat confusing party line that the funds were never in question and the policy was interpreted all wrong anyway, and even if they had interpreted the policy right, they didn't really mean it.
Since many Americans view Planned Parenthood as their friendly neighbourhood Abortion Store, where children go to get sex advice and fetuses go to get killed, I'll just cite, once more, the fact that less that 3% of what PP actually does is administer abortions. Despite Republicans' insistence that abortions are the Thing Planned Parenthood Does, what PP really does is provide a full range of medical care for men and women who would otherwise go without. This includes physicals, mental health concerns, cancer screening, and yes, also sexual health guidance.
I live in Canada, where Planned Parenthood serves a different role in my community - I don't get a bill no matter which doctor I go to, so Planned Parenthood Toronto is a community health center that serves the under-29 crowd. I've been a patient there for years, and their staff has walked me through annual check-ups, made referrals for me to get my ovaries (okay, ovary) monitored, been a part of an excellent arts-oriented anxiety therapy group, and generally had my health needs served. They're part of my emotional landscape - I get twitchy when people suggest that PP is a dangerous organization, because they care for people. They care for me.
America is weird. If you fall and break your leg, you pay for the cost of your care. If you fall and break your leg because, say, someone failed to shovel their front walk and you slipped on some ice, many, many people will tell you to sue, which is a necessary, but mean, option in a land where cancer treatments will run a person (or their insurance company) upwards of $100,000 in a lifetime. The American approach to health care isn't the "shit happens" ethos that socialized health care allows a patient to adopt; it's the "let's find out whose fault this is and then sue the shit out of them" ideology that comes from capitalism, and from saying, either implicitly or explicitly, that anyone who fails to hit the big time is just not yanking on their bootstraps hard enough.
Susan G. Komen, who was best known for a billion pink ribbons, is a large company. They've become famous for their corporate partnerships - KitchenAid, for example, will produce a special stand-up mixer in that trademark breast-cancer pink, and the proceeds from those sales will be directed to research (a lot of the proceeds will be go towards the cost of organizing all those partnerships, but some funds will get into the lab, eventually, probably). SGK has come under fire in recent years - for the litigious approach towards other organizations who use the phrase "for the cure," for partnering with companies whose products contain cancer-causing ingredients, for creating a culture where breast cancer diagnoses are dipped in pink and there's no room for rage - but the PP misstep was disastrous.
The official party line was that SGK would not fund organizations who were under investigation by local, state or federal authorities. As it happens, Planned Parenthood was under investigation by a right-wing Congressional committee for allegedly providing abortions with taxpayer money (abortions are still legal in America, by the way). As it also happens, PP was the only one of the more than 2,000 organizations that receive SGK funding that was affected by the new policy.
Cue shitstorm.
Planned Parenthood gets a lot of flack in America for being an abortion provider, but let's face it: that country is weird about reproductive rights. There was a national debate in the last decade about wether or not a pharmacist could refuse to fill a prescription for Plan B - a common morning-after contraceptive that, in Canada, is available without a scrip - if the scrip conflicted with the pharmacist's position on birth control. These kinds of debates are still happening, which is outrageous. This debate is literally about wether or not a woman has access to the kinds of drugs she needs because she's a woman. It's patronizing, condescending, and forces women to ask permission for things that are rights - the right to govern her own body, to put into it what she thinks is best, and to not have folks make a big deal about it.
But the big deal remains. What's frustrating about this case is that it's woman-on-woman financial violence, and the women in question are all under the pressures of needing medical care. Nobody goes to Planned Parenthood to just, like, loiter: we go because we need care, and they give it. And by the same token, nobody gets involved in Komen fundraising because they're bored: they go because they, or their mother/aunt/sister/boss/daughter got some bad news about her tits. There should be solidarity in that stance, not distance.
Even if Komen restores all the funding and then some, I doubt that Planned Parenthood will ever really feel secure about their financial position. America is still too sharply divided about something as basic as human reproductive rights to let the issue quietly go away. Which is a shame, because there's so much more to women than pink ribbons and abortions.
Wednesday, February 1, 2012
Feeling Your Shitty Feelings
Last weekend, I was part of Pressgang Theater's storytelling night, "Narcotics Synonymous." The night centered around tales of drugging and drinking, and since of all of us were in our twenties, it was far less depressing than it could have been. I told the story of my very first bad hangover, and it was captured for posterity by Liz, who apologies profusely for both letting the camera wander and sitting too close to her guffawing husband.
My boyfriend pointed out that the story was basically just a blog post, live-styles. In that spirit, I present it to you.
I feel ambivalent about how I look (I have one chin too many, and the lights washed me out something fierce), but I'm grateful for the chance to be part of something like this. Blogging is personal, and rarely performed, so it was challenging and refreshing to do something with immediate, visceral feedback. Thank you to those in the audience who laughed, and if you laugh at home, bless you. I thought there was nothing lonelier than a blog entry without comments; as it turns out, it's a joke where nobody laughs.
My boyfriend pointed out that the story was basically just a blog post, live-styles. In that spirit, I present it to you.
I feel ambivalent about how I look (I have one chin too many, and the lights washed me out something fierce), but I'm grateful for the chance to be part of something like this. Blogging is personal, and rarely performed, so it was challenging and refreshing to do something with immediate, visceral feedback. Thank you to those in the audience who laughed, and if you laugh at home, bless you. I thought there was nothing lonelier than a blog entry without comments; as it turns out, it's a joke where nobody laughs.
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Blah-scar Nominations
When I was younger, the Academy Awards were the living end: the pinnacle of glamour, the acme of accomplishment, the very height of American can-do attitude with a healthy dose of beaded gowns. The red carpet, the shots of an audience in stitches - when I first started watching, the show was hosted by Billy Crystal, who was irascibly, harmlessly funny - the tearful speeches, the interminable running time: it felt so big, like everyone who mattered was in that room that night, and they were all dressed to impress.
Seen through the eyes of a child - a child slightly obsessed with old Hollywood, who, in the sixth grade, wrote a report on the Fatty Arbuckle scandal - the Oscars represented the untouchable loveliness of Hollywood. 1994 was the first year I watched, and the show was both a tease (those clips! Of Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption!) and a barge (it lasted for hours: it was literally the longest show I had ever watched). In more recent years, the Academy has done away with some of the stateliness, and the clips are a little less enticing, but it's still basically celebrating the best of cinemasphere.
Or is it?
Yesterday, the nominees for 2012 were announced, and, like every year, there's backlash. "Where's The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo? What's Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close doing in there? Do I spy Transformers 3: Dark Side of the Moon on that list?" Lists like this are always contentious, because film, like all other art forms, is subjective. The Academy has always revelled in a certain filmic elitism: comedies never get nominated, animated features have been ghettoized, and the movies that actually get seen by regular civilians are nowhere to be found.
Example: Tin-Tin was a marvellous movie, full of action and comedy and excellent performances. The Academy, though, is slow to adapt to changing technologies like motion- and performance capture, so movies like Tin-Tin, that use emerging techniques in order to make some truly stellar movie moments, get ignored. Don't believe me? Do you honestly believe that Puss in Boots, a Shrek spin-off that was pretty much greeted with "Did we really need this?" deserves an Oscar more than the beautifully choreographed chase through Morocco?
Or the question of motion capture, period: Andy Serkis, who has made his living playing characters that aren't quite human (Gollum, Cesar in Rise of the Planet of the Apes, the animated Captain Haddock in Tin-Tin). He does beautiful, subtle work. But he often does it in a motion-capture suit, and the character's is filled in around him in post-production. Serkis doesn't look like George Clooney or Brad Pitt, but his characters are creations that straddle the line between "human" and "other," and after this summer's Rise, there was a motion from fans to recognize good work.
The Academy ignored that work completely.
As I get older, I realize that the Oscars aren't really about celebrating what's truly great, even though that does sometimes happen: The Artist is nominated this year, and it should win. The other nominees were divisive: Tree of Life, The Help and Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close split the critics, and flicks like War Horse are such transparent Oscar-bait that I avoid them out of a sense of duty. But mostly, the Best Picture nods always take themselves so seriously: so many dramas and period pieces, so many dying kids and dying moms and failing husbands and injured animals - it's all too much.
Part of it is growing up, and becoming less enamoured with Hollywood - the old-time glamour is gone. The machinery of the industry is much more in-your-face. Box office get discussed around water coolers. Comedies get ignored at awards shows. I've aged out of the demographic that will take in every last thing Hollywood says as gospel: the cacophony of awards and critics isn't silenced by the Oscars, only frothed up further. I wonder if my kids will crouch by the TV on the night of the Oscars, breathlessly watching the Hollywood elite celebrate each other's work. I somehow doubt it. Part of me doubts that I'll be there, either.
Sunday, January 22, 2012
Your Mommyblog Doesn't Wear Combat Boots
Last year, mommyblogs were all the rage, and Mormon mommyblogs were especially au courant. Slate published a shamefaced essay, written by a self-proclaimed feminist who couldn't tear herself away from all the shiny, happy young women who were photoblogging and writing love notes to their impossibly handsome husbands. Emily Matchar, the author of the Slate article, wrote about her cringe-y, self-judging relationship with these blogs: as a young feminist,she wasn't really looking to become a young stay-at-home wife and mother, making pom-pom garlands and jellies. But Matchar talked about craving the other side of the post-feminist discourse, the one that doesn't focus on BPA in the baby bottles, episiotomies, and work-life-balance fraught terror of screwing up your kids while your kid, in turn, ruins your own professional and personal life.
When these sprightly blogs cross my path,I fall on them like wolves on sheep. I want to read every entry of each blog, but as I go through and look at wedding pictures (the dresses are all sacks, the bride and groom are undergrads), I feel a creeping queasiness. I'm jealous...and also angry...and then glad they're not me...and then jealous again.
The Mormon mommyblogs seem so simple: gratitude flows from each entry. They're the polar opposite of most young people's personal blog. I've always had more glass-half-empty stuff to say, and online, it become very easy for a blog to become a litany of moody song lyrics, YouTube videos that will somehow express how I feel, links to bummer news stories, and Instagram posts of half-done crosswords, half-eaten meals, and half-drank pints. We're kind of a downer, at least on the internet. Compared to the mommyblogs, which feature sweeping images of the Utah mountainscape (so gorgeous I would consider converting just to live there [Not really. --Ed.]), my life is blah, boring. Their sun shines constantly.
One of my high school teachers once asked me what I wanted to do after I graduated. I shrugged and said, "I dunno, what are the qualifications for becoming a mom?" I've never actually had huge biological clock urges - even now I feel worried about things like baby weight and whether or not it's okay to let your infant just sleep on the floor (on a mat! I suspect the answer is still no, though). But there's something very primal and instinctual about becoming a parent. These young women have become more than parents, though. I would say that they're super-moms, but I don't mean that their parenting skills are any better than mine would be. They just seem to have their shit together, in a way that I am very far away from.
Part of the appeal of blogging, as Matchar points out, is that not everything you do, say, or think needs to make an appearance. My own blog, through sprawling in its scope, doesn't touch on everything, and the Mormon mommybloggers keep it even tinier. There are lovely photos of their young children and of large family parties. There are posts about pregnancy, and dinners with friends. There are video montages about Christmas. But their professional lives don't get mentioned - it's easy to imagine that these women spend all their time grooming their toddlers and choosing the perfect red lipstick, and that jobs are something for husbands and fathers, not for them. Larger social issues almost never get raised - these girls will never post about Mitt Romney or fiscal responsibility, not when their kids are doing something adorable.
The effect of these willful blind spots is that these writers seem to be transmitting from inside a snow globe - their lives are so beautiful, so magically perfect, that it's impossible to see if they work at the magic, and if they do, how hard. None of the seams show, but that also means there's no crack for me to sneak through. It's life, in a vacuum, with the perfect shade of red lipstick.
When these sprightly blogs cross my path,I fall on them like wolves on sheep. I want to read every entry of each blog, but as I go through and look at wedding pictures (the dresses are all sacks, the bride and groom are undergrads), I feel a creeping queasiness. I'm jealous...and also angry...and then glad they're not me...and then jealous again.
The Mormon mommyblogs seem so simple: gratitude flows from each entry. They're the polar opposite of most young people's personal blog. I've always had more glass-half-empty stuff to say, and online, it become very easy for a blog to become a litany of moody song lyrics, YouTube videos that will somehow express how I feel, links to bummer news stories, and Instagram posts of half-done crosswords, half-eaten meals, and half-drank pints. We're kind of a downer, at least on the internet. Compared to the mommyblogs, which feature sweeping images of the Utah mountainscape (so gorgeous I would consider converting just to live there [Not really. --Ed.]), my life is blah, boring. Their sun shines constantly.
One of my high school teachers once asked me what I wanted to do after I graduated. I shrugged and said, "I dunno, what are the qualifications for becoming a mom?" I've never actually had huge biological clock urges - even now I feel worried about things like baby weight and whether or not it's okay to let your infant just sleep on the floor (on a mat! I suspect the answer is still no, though). But there's something very primal and instinctual about becoming a parent. These young women have become more than parents, though. I would say that they're super-moms, but I don't mean that their parenting skills are any better than mine would be. They just seem to have their shit together, in a way that I am very far away from.
Part of the appeal of blogging, as Matchar points out, is that not everything you do, say, or think needs to make an appearance. My own blog, through sprawling in its scope, doesn't touch on everything, and the Mormon mommybloggers keep it even tinier. There are lovely photos of their young children and of large family parties. There are posts about pregnancy, and dinners with friends. There are video montages about Christmas. But their professional lives don't get mentioned - it's easy to imagine that these women spend all their time grooming their toddlers and choosing the perfect red lipstick, and that jobs are something for husbands and fathers, not for them. Larger social issues almost never get raised - these girls will never post about Mitt Romney or fiscal responsibility, not when their kids are doing something adorable.
The effect of these willful blind spots is that these writers seem to be transmitting from inside a snow globe - their lives are so beautiful, so magically perfect, that it's impossible to see if they work at the magic, and if they do, how hard. None of the seams show, but that also means there's no crack for me to sneak through. It's life, in a vacuum, with the perfect shade of red lipstick.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
